Effect of Air Particle Abrasion Methods on Shear Bond Strength of Resin Cement to Zirconia (In vitro study)
Abstract
Purpose: To compare between the effect of chair-side and laboratory air particle abrasion
(APA) on shear bond strength of different types of zirconia to composite resin.
Materials and Methods: Study was divided into two groups (n=36): laboratory (L) and
chair-side (C) according to APA application. Each group was further divided into 3 subgroups
according to type of zirconia used (High-Translucency (HT), Super-Translucency (ST), and Top-
Translucency (TT)).Using CADCAM 8x8x3mm zirconia specimens were constructed, cleaned
and sintered. Composite specimens having dimensions of 6x6x3mm were also constructed using
custom made plexi plates. Composite specimens were cemented centrally to the zirconia
specimens with light cure under 5kg for 6 mins. After thermo cycling for 1000 cycles, all
specimens were dried and collected for testing. The shear bond strength of the specimens was
measured utilizing universal testing machine at a crosshead speed of 0.5 mm/min. The failure
load was recorded in Newton. The SBS was calculated as follows:
SBS (MPa) = load (N)/area(mm2).
Results: Chair-side high translucency (CHT) scored the highest mean SBS (12.69±5.59)
followed by chair-side super translucency (CST) (11.38±3.42) and then chair-side top
translucency (CTT) (8.13±3.4). All chair-side mean SBS values were more than lab SBS values.
lab high translucency (LHT) (7.87±5.17), lab top translucency (LTT) (7.4±5.75) and the least
was lab super translucency (LST) (6.00±2.48). T-student test revealed significant difference
between tested groups (P=0.001).
Conclusion: There was a significant difference between chair-side and laboratory APA.
Chair-side APA showed higher mean values of SBS and may present a logical and practical
alternative to lab APA in treating zirconia surfaces before cementation.
Key words: super-translucency zirconia, top-translucency zirconia, high-translucency
zirconia, translucency, chair side APA, laboratory APA.
Student(s)
Dana Abed El Baset Ballouli
Supervisor(s)
Prof. Essam Osman and Dr. Mohammad Rayyan