Influence of Etching Capacity of Universal Adhesives on Bonding to Dentin Using Two Etching Strategies (In Vitro Study)
Abstract
Aim: the objective of this study was to evaluate the effect of etching capacity of three universal
adhesives having different pH on bonding effectiveness to dentin using two etching strategies.
Methods: Eighty-four extracted sound premolar teeth were selected for the study. The coronal
part was sectioned to reveal a flat dentinal surface. The teeth were ultra-sonically cleaned for 15
minutes and stored at room temperature in demineralized water. The polished specimens were
randomly divided into three main groups: moderate (pH range 1-2), mild (pH range 2-2.5), and
ultra-mild (pH range >2.5). Each group was further divided into two sub-groups (n=14)
according to etching strategy (ER) or (SE). Hollow cylinders of 0.75 mm internal diameter and
4.0 mm in height were cut from micro-borne rubber tubing and placed over the treated dentin
surface and a nanohybrid resin composite was packed into the cylinders using a suitable diameter
applicator and polymerized using a light-curing unit. After storage in demineralized water at
37 C for 24 hours half of the groups were assigned for immediate testing while the other half
were assigned for 15000 thermocycling. The specimens were examined under scanning electron
microscope to examine the bonding surface and characterize the failure mode. The μSBS values
and mode of failure were recorded and statistically analyzed using three-way ANOVA test.
Results: etching capacity, etching strategy and thermocycling had a statistically significant effect
on mean μSBS. The interaction between the three variables had no statistically significant effect
on mean μSBS; therefore the variables are independent from each other. Regardless of etching
strategy and thermocycling, moderate group showed the statistically significantly highest mean
μSBS. Mild group showed statistically significantly lower mean value. Ultra-mild group showed
the statistically significantly lowest mean μSBS. Regardless of etching capacity group and
thermocycling, ER showed statistically significantly higher mean μSBS than SE. Regardless of
etching capacity and etching strategy, there was a statistically significantly decrease in mean
μSBS after thermocycling. For mode of failure, with ER strategy, either immediately or after
thermocycling, all specimens showed cohesive failure thus, no comparisons were done. With SE
strategy, either immediately or after thermocycling, all specimens showed cohesive and adhesive
failures, so there was no statistically significant difference in mode of failure among the three
groups.
Conclusion:
Within the limitations of this study:
1. The etching capacity of universal adhesives and the etching strategy may influence bonding
effectiveness to dentin.
2. The intermediate pH (range 1-2) seems to have better bond quality to dentin than mild and
ultra-mild pH (range 2-2.5, pH > 2.5 respectively).
3. The μSBS of universal adhesives could be improved with the use of ER strategy.
4. Thermal aging appears to influence the μSBS of universal adhesives..
5. Bonding performance of universal adhesives used in this study is material dependent.
Student(s)
Yassir Hammed Edan Zyara
Supervisor(s)
Prof. Essam Osman and Dr. Hala Ragab